Subscribe To This Site
XML RSS
Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Subscribe with Bloglines
Home
Administrative Contact Us
Link Partners
Terms Of Use
Affiliate Disclosure
Newsletter
Privacy Policy
Healthy Planet Green Partners
Planet Earth Central
Articles Central
Business Central
Visitor Forums Whats New
Berry Blogger
Testimonials
Academic Athlete
My Story
Teen Central
Forum Chat
Cafe Wear
Wellness Wellness Central
ACAI Retail Store
Total Fitness
Exotic Fruits
eBook Store
 

Was There A Jewish President?

by Rabbi Jeff Kahn
(Temple Har Shalom, Warren N.J.)

Abraham Lincoln was Jewish?

Abraham Lincoln was Jewish?

The work Rabbi Jeff Kahn:


"On the twelfth of February, 1809, nearly 200 years ago, a young, poor illiterate woman from Virginia, Nancy Hanks Lincoln, gave birth to a son, in a log cabin, built along the banks of the south fork of
Nolin Creek, near what is now Hodgenville, Kentucky. That baby, whom she named Abraham, grew to become one of our greatest, and most tragic, national leaders.

Lincoln was a man of great spiritual conviction. Yet, and I find this fact fascinatingly instructive, Abraham Lincoln was the only American president not to have declared himself a member of any particular religious faith. That fact has given rise to a great deal of interesting speculation. In fact, there are those who believe that

Honest Abe was Jewish.After all, his name was Abraham. His great-grandfather was named Mordechai. Lincoln was the only President not to have a formal religious affiliation. He was neither raised in a church nor did he ever belong to a church.

And there's more... the town of Lincoln, in eastern England, whence his ancestors came, has an interesting Jewish history. A Jewish community was established there in 1159. During Crusader riots, the Sheriff of Lincoln saved the Jews by giving them official
protection. St. Hugh, the great Bishop of Lincoln, taught love of Jews to his parishioners. His death was marked by an official period of mourning among Lincoln's Jews. Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln was a scholar mentioned in the Talmud; Aaron of Lincoln was a financier whose operations extended all over the country.

In 1255, Lincoln's Jews were accused of ritual murder. Ninety-one Lincoln Jews were sent to London for trial and 18 were executed. Notwithstanding, the Lincoln Jewish community flourished until 1290, when they were forcibly expelled by edict.

Most Jewish historians assume that all the Jews of Lincoln left in 1290. But could it be possible that some remained, practicing their Judaism in secret...passing the family secret from generation to
generation? The more we learn of the secret life of Spanish Jewry following the Expulsion of 1492, the more we must at least consider the possibility of the same thing occurring elsewhere.

When Abraham Lincoln was assassinated, whole Jewish communities sat shivah. Rabbis all over the country eulogized the fallen President. Rabbi Isaac Mayer Wise, the man who created Reform Judaism in this country, began his eulogy with the words...
"Brethren, the lamented Abraham Lincoln believed himself to be bone from our bone and flesh from our flesh. He supposed himself to be a descendant of Hebrew parentage He said so in my presence."

Lincoln was often questioned about his religious beliefs. Time and again, he told of a special passage from Scripture that summed up his theology. It was the twentieth chapter of the Book of Exodus he recommended that every American study, learn and follow. In English it is usually referred to as the Ten Commandments."

Rabbi Jeff Kahn
Temple Har Shalom, Warren, N.J.

Comments for
Was There A Jewish President?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Jan 29, 2012
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Re: Black Dutch Lincoln
by: Darren

This topic is very addicting. I would love to learn more if more people would exchange their knowledge here it would be fantastic...any other Lincoln theories or facts?

Darren

Dec 01, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Black Dutch Lincoln
by: Anonymous

I came upon this page because I'm researching Black Dutch heritage. The mother of Lincoln, Nancy Hanks, was said to have been born in Pocohontas County in what is now West Virginia and was of Black Dutch heritage.

I am a West Virginian of Black Dutch heritage and I can give you my DNA results which should, if Nancy was Black Dutch, be similar to President Lincoln.

I did show Middle Eastern DNA, a haplogroup that originated in Mesopotamia, was found in Egyptian mummies, Hebrews and 71% of all Palestinians are of this Haplogroup. I showed a great among of Native American DNA, which I found out was Blackfoot-Saponi and Shawnee, and lastly, the typical western European from Scot-Irish ancestors. I also matched Brahmin DNA in India.

The Middle Eastern remains a mystery. I doubt it came from Lincoln, England though, there is too much of it and it had to come in later than the 1100s. The Middle Eastern DNA is high in Southern Germany and Ireland, where some of my ancestors came from.

Just thought you might want to know. I wish the would do a DNA test because this is fascinating. My great-grandmother's mouth looked just like Lincolns. It's just odd.

Sep 24, 2011
Rating
starstarstar
was there a jewish presedent?
by: rster

Lincoln could have been jewish but somewhere in his family the Lincolns must have become christian because my friends last name is Lincoln and is related to Abraham but is christian

Sep 14, 2011
Rating
starstarstar
To: Terry
by: Anonymous

Hey Terry, I'm a right wing extremists, and a Jew, and I never liked Abraham Lincoln, he tore our country apart and I am VERY VERY offended that they are saying that Abe Lincoln was Jewish, it is indespicable.

Sep 14, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
About the Yuya mummy (previous comment)
by: Shimon

Yuya cannot be Joseph, because the Bible makes it very clear that Moses took Joseph's bones from Egypt
and was eventually buried in Shechem, Israel, along with his two sons, whose gravesites are visited by Jews all the time. That is, unless you don't believe in the Bible...

Sep 14, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Melungeon
by: Anonymous

Abraham Lincoln was a Melungeon. This means that he might have had Jewish origins, as well as Black Dutch (Gypsy).

Jun 23, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstar
Look to the Mummies
by: Anonymous

I am not of Jewish heritage, that I know of, but my husband and I have a great respect for the vital role they have played in civilizing the world. We especially love Moses Mendelssohn's writings, his collaboration with Lessing, and the great culture they developed in Germany.

My remarks will be brief, and not very scientific. But my husband and I were STUNNED when examining an image of Yuya's mummy; the one suspected, by many, to be the very Joseph of the many colored coat, whose brother's sold him into slavery.

If you get on Google, request an image of the mummy of Yuya, click Images, and then Search, you will be amazed at the quality of "Yuya's" face. In addition to his hands being in a praying position, unlike the hands of other Egyptian mummies, his face, so beautifully strong, and vital, looks so much like Abraham Lincoln. He must have received a very high quality burial, because his head and face are of a much better quality than any others I have ever seen! It's a little unsettling to behold. But, do go there if you haven't already.

Enjoyed your comments. They are very helpful with respect to gaining a better understanding of our greatest President's contribution to the world.

Shalom!

Mar 09, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Perfect
by: Terry

Perfect. This will drive all those freaky right-wingers in the State completely crazy. Their most beloved and quoted President being Jewish!!! I will giggle myself to sleep tonight.

Feb 27, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
FAILED SCHOLARSHIP
by: Anonymous

UNPROVEN
by: ananymous

THE AUTHOR'S LETTER APPEARS BELOW. IT IS AN ADMISSION OF FAILED SCHOLARSHIP. YOU MAY CONTACT HIM YOURSELF. YITZI


Aug 19, 2008

Rabbi's email to me
by: YITZI

Shalom Yitzi
Thanks so much for your email.

What a long, strange trip it has been! With more than a quarter century in the congregational rabbinate, hundreds and hundreds of sermons and articles (some pretty good, I think), this seems to be my claim to fame. Over the past couple of years, I've heard from hundreds of people all over the world about this one, which seems to have taken on a life of its own.

Here's what happened: Three or four years ago, while serving in Central Jersey , I preached a Shabbat sermon close to President's Day about Washington and Lincoln's relationships with American Jewry. I spoke about Washington's visit to Newport and his message to American Jews, as well has his relationship with Haym Solomon. I spoke about Grant's infamous Orders 11, Jewish protests to Lincoln & his telegram to Grant, as well as his establishment of the military Jewish chaplaincy. All the usual stuff. I then went on to report of Isaac Mayer Wise's eulogy of Lincoln, in which he claimed Lincoln to be â??bone of our boneâ? and added some of the more bizarre claims of Lincoln's Jewishness.

An uncle of one of the B'nai Mitzvah that Shabbat gave his twist of that part of the sermon to his friend, NY Post gossip columnist Cindy Adams, who included it in her next column. Immediately, I began to hear from congregants who had read Cindy Adam's piece, but had not heard my sermon, wanting to know what I had said. In response, I included that part of the sermon in the weekly e-mail to the congregation. I guess some forwarded it to others and a chain of forwarding began. Within days I began hearing from people from all over the world Jews, gentiles, Lincoln scholars, an incredible collection. even several high school and college friends with whom I had been out of touch for decades. And each year, around Lincoln's birthday, I hear from more and more people.

To answer your question: I have absolutely NO idea where I got the line about Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln . I am sure I didn't just make it up, I must have read it somewhere, but, obviously, it canâ??t be true. Perhaps I misread it. Perhaps it was miswritten. Or perhaps the guy who wrote it originally made it up. For the record, I don't know if there ever was a Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln , but I have learned to be careful of what I put in an email. And, should you ever find anything about a Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln quoted in the Talmud, let me know. I've heard from a lot of people who want to know more about him!

On a far more important note, I'm deeply appreciate the emails you've been sending. Sounds like we're on the same wave-length.

Shalom from Israel

Jeffrey Kahn

Rabbi Jeffrey Kahn

Rehov Hadar 61a, Apt 6

Herzliya 46326 ISRAEL

(09) 954-0272

Direct from the US : (646) 485-7325

Feb 27, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Abraham Lincoln A Jewish President
by: Cary

Reece,

Thank you for sharing. I have been coming back to this little corner of the internet to check on any ancestor comments and sure enough here is yours. I find this fascinating and quite frankly Im surprised the history books have never (to my findings) ever really talked about this.

Do you have any letters between family members that talks to the subject?

Cary

Feb 27, 2011
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
If Abe's Jewish than I'm Jewish
by: Reece Lincoln

Interesting that there was Mordecai, Abraham and Sarah in the Bible and there was Abraham Lincoln, his sister Sarah and his great great grandpa Mordecai. Also interesting that the town of Lincoln in Lincolnshire where his ancestory most likley took on the name Lincoln, was a very prominent Jewish town.

I'm a cousin to Abe Lincoln and our direct ancestory meets at Mordecai. It's very possible that even if he was of Jewish ancestory he may not of known for sure himself. What I do believe though is that the Lincoln family past and present have a love for the Jewish people.

Reece Lincoln

www.reecelincoln.com

Jan 27, 2011
Rating
starstarstar
Who knew?
by: Anonymous

I don't believe any one of us could tell for certain if Abraham Lincoln was Jewish or not. Christians will say he was Christian, Jews will say he was Jewish, etc. No one who knew him is still alive, and if you come back and say they are, I'd like to see their dusty old bones.

Pardon my vehemance ;)

Nov 04, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Lincold Being Jewish
by: Antoinne

Its intriguing but like some of the experts state below this is very hard to believe and this sounds more like urban legend and fun and games rather than old fashioned proof by research.

He was truly a great Leader based on the history we have been able to uncover. The stories on all great leaders is sometimes stretched but I find this one hard to take seriously in the direction intended here.

Antoinne

Sep 26, 2010
Rating
starstar
Don't Trivialize Genealogy
by: Rfael Guber

Lincoln having Jewish ancestry I might buy. Lincoln being Jewish is a real stretch. Were the Todd's "Jewish too? Even by Reform standards he would not be Jewish because he never publically proclaimed a Matrilineal or Patralineal Jewish ancestry. With all due respect, as a professional genealogist for twenty years, this is more parlor game than genealogy. Frankly confusing historical speculation with genealogy trivializes what genealogy really is. It like letting your barber perform open heart searching because he knows how to hold a pair of sissors.

Regarding Professor Elizabeth Hirschman'S "PROOF"- in the immortal words of John Lennon. "We'd all love to see the plan."

Rafael Guber

Member Association of Professional Genealogists

May 26, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Lincoln was in fact a Jewish
by: Anonymous

Abraham Lincoln always said : religion is personal should not be mixed with govenment or business. He kept it to himself . Lincoln is the only president who did not sworn in the Bible , he sworn in the Constitution , that why he was elected to protect the Constitution of the U.S. Lincoln had a Torah that he always read, he had instructions that when he died his Torah should be burned and the ashes spread secretly around his tumb , all his family are jewish (do the resesearh) Lincoln favored to free the Slaves , remembered his people in Egipt. Lincoln said "It does not matter who I worship , The goverment is by the people and for the people

Apr 18, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
A Jewish President in America
by: Anonymous

Considering all these comments back to 2008 it really makes you wonder about Abraham Lincoln and the possibility that he was a Jewish President after all these decades have passed us by. Who knows.

Maybe we should take some of the USA Stimulus Funds and find out. Seems like we waste enough money on the failed Banks in our country why not find out once and for all about this.

Sep 08, 2009
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
President Lincoln Jewish
by: Kathy

Since I wasn't there and no one in my southern Kentucky legacy has any written proof I tend to believe this is all hogwash. But where there is smoke there is fire and this thread seems to have kindled something of interest.

Anyone have proof of Honest Abe being Jewish?

Kathy

Sep 08, 2009
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Was Lincoln a Jew
by: Anonymous

There was an Exilearch of the Jews that was surnamed Lincoln.There is speculation in Ky that he had jewish ancestry.

Mar 08, 2009
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Lincoln was not Jewish
by: Arthur

Had he been Jewish the Civil Rights issues would have been resolved much quicker. North vs. South? Never would have come to that. This was one smart cookie but he lacked the right genes for a quick decision thus my observation that this Jewish thing is just a ton of fun for the internet.

Jan 23, 2009
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
A US Jewish President
by: Kristie

Now come on everyone. Don't you all think of there was a Jewish President in our history we would have all known it by now. In fact, we wouldnt be in the mess we are in financially if that was the case. Now we have Obama who is already back tracking on his campaign promises.

We need Hillary!!

Jan 19, 2009
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
A Jewish President and Now
by: Carl

On the eve of the historic inauguration of Barrack Obama it is moving to think that a hidden Jewish President has escaped our naked eye. One can only wonder what the past has hidden away from all to understand and witness.

Oct 28, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
UNPROVEN
by: ananymous

THE AUTHOR'S LETTER APPEARS BELOW. IT IS AN ADMISSION OF FAILED SCHOLARSHIP. YOU MAY CONTACT HIM YOURSELF. YITZI


Aug 19, 2008

Rabbi's email to me
by: YITZI

Shalom Yitzi
Thanks so much for your email.

What a long, strange trip it has been! With more than a quarter century in the congregational rabbinate, hundreds and hundreds of sermons and articles (some pretty good, I think), this seems to be my claim to fame. Over the past couple of years, I've heard from hundreds of people all over the world about this one, which seems to have taken on a life of its own.

Here's what happened: Three or four years ago, while serving in Central Jersey , I preached a Shabbat sermon close to President's Day about Washington and Lincoln's relationships with American Jewry. I spoke about Washington's visit to Newport and his message to American Jews, as well has his relationship with Haym Solomon. I spoke about Grant's infamous Orders 11, Jewish protests to Lincoln & his telegram to Grant, as well as his establishment of the military Jewish chaplaincy. All the usual stuff. I then went on to report of Isaac Mayer Wise's eulogy of Lincoln, in which he claimed Lincoln to be â??bone of our boneâ? and added some of the more bizarre claims of Lincoln's Jewishness.

An uncle of one of the B'nai Mitzvah that Shabbat gave his twist of that part of the sermon to his friend, NY Post gossip columnist Cindy Adams, who included it in her next column. Immediately, I began to hear from congregants who had read Cindy Adam's piece, but had not heard my sermon, wanting to know what I had said. In response, I included that part of the sermon in the weekly e-mail to the congregation. I guess some forwarded it to others and a chain of forwarding began. Within days I began hearing from people from all over the world Jews, gentiles, Lincoln scholars, an incredible collection. even several high school and college friends with whom I had been out of touch for decades. And each year, around Lincoln's birthday, I hear from more and more people.

To answer your question: I have absolutely NO idea where I got the line about Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln . I am sure I didn't just make it up, I must have read it somewhere, but, obviously, it canâ??t be true. Perhaps I misread it. Perhaps it was miswritten. Or perhaps the guy who wrote it originally made it up. For the record, I don't know if there ever was a Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln , but I have learned to be careful of what I put in an email. And, should you ever find anything about a Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln quoted in the Talmud, let me know. I've heard from a lot of people who want to know more about him!

On a far more important note, I'm deeply appreciate the emails you've been sending. Sounds like we're on the same wave-length.

Shalom from Israel

Jeffrey Kahn

Rabbi Jeffrey Kahn

Rehov Hadar 61a, Apt 6

Herzliya 46326 ISRAEL

(09) 954-0272

Direct from the US : (646) 485-7325



Oct 28, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Lincoln A Jewish President
by: Jacob

Abraham Lincoln was Jewish? This one certainly can be proven I or found to be incorrect I would think? He was a President for crying out loud there has to be some record of his practiced faith wouldn't there?

Someone in the Know please advise

Oct 16, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Cool!!!!
by: Anonymous

I never thought that Abraham Lincon could be Jewish!!!!

Oct 15, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Jewish President in America
by: Anonymous

Wow, the internet is a wonderful place to learn new things. Where on earth do these things come from. President Lincoln presumably a Jewish President?

It's hard to imagine and certainly it is questionable reading through all of these replies. But look at us now? We are about to get our first African American born in Hawaii President raised by his grandparents in Barack Obama.

It is truly a free world now.

Sep 27, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Jewish President and History
by: Anonymous

Is this on the level? I have researched this as well but never finding the type of records that make any sense at all. The timing of the statements and relative history we do know is not linking up in my simple mind.

Sep 04, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
wow
by: Anonymous

a friend asked me if we ever had a jewish president and i put up this search and found this out!

Aug 27, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Abe Lincoln Jewish
by: Debbie in Tulsa

Six degrees of separation for all I suppose. I can hardly believe some of the information that keeps coming out of the internet. What a wonderful medium this is and a nice place to meet and greet people of similar interests.

Wish we had this when I was in college.

Debbie

Aug 19, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Rabbi's email to me
by: YITZI

Shalom Yitzi –



Thanks so much for your email.



What a long, strange trip it has been! With more than a quarter century in the congregational rabbinate, hundreds and hundreds of sermons and articles (some pretty good, I think), this seems to be my claim to fame. Over the past couple of years, I’ve heard from hundreds of people all over the world about this one, which seems to have taken on a life of its own.



Here’s what happened: Three or four years ago, while serving in Central Jersey , I preached a Shabbat sermon close to President’s Day about Washington and Lincoln’s relationships with American Jewry. I spoke about Washington ’s visit to Newport and his message to American Jews, as well has his relationship with Haym Solomon. I spoke about Grant’s infamous Orders 11, Jewish protests to Lincoln & his telegram to Grant, as well as his establishment of the military Jewish chaplaincy. All the usual stuff. I then went on to report of Isaac Mayer Wise’s eulogy of Lincoln, in which he claimed Lincoln to be “bone of our bone†and added some of the more bizarre claims of Lincoln’s Jewishness.



An uncle of one of the B’nai Mitzvah that Shabbat gave his twist of that part of the sermon to his friend, NY Post gossip columnist Cindy Adams, who included it in her next column. Immediately, I began to hear from congregants who had read Cindy Adam’s piece, but had not heard my sermon, wanting to know what I had said. In response, I included that part of the sermon in the weekly e-mail to the congregation. I guess some forwarded it to others and a chain of forwarding began. Within days I began hearing from people from all over the world – Jews, gentiles, Lincoln scholars, an incredible collection. – even several high school and college friends with whom I had been out of touch for decades. And each year, around Lincoln ’s birthday, I hear from more and more people.



To answer your question: I have absolutely NO idea where I got the line about Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln . I’m sure I didn’t just make it up, I must have read it somewhere, but, obviously, it can’t be true. Perhaps I misread it. Perhaps it was miswritten. Or perhaps the guy who wrote it originally made it up. For the record, I don’t know if there ever was a Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln , but I have learned to be careful of what I put in an email. And, should you ever find anything about a Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln quoted in the Talmud, let me know – I’ve heard from a lot of people who want to know more about him!



On a far more important note, I’m deeply appreciate the emails you’ve been sending. Sounds like we’re on the same wave-length.



Shalom from Israel –



Jeffrey Kahn





Rabbi Jeffrey Kahn

Rehov Hadar 61a, Apt 6

Herzliya 46326 ISRAEL

(09) 954-0272

Direct from the US : (646) 485-7325


Aug 18, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
The Talmud and the Rabbi
by: Anonymous

So, from a pure timing perspective how could this all be true?

May 03, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Rabbi Jeff Kahn
by: Anonymous

Do a search on Rabbi Jeff Kahn...you should find his information there. I found this online doing just that: http://recoveringliberal.com/?p=569


Apr 16, 2008
Rating
starstarstar
In the Talmud?
by: Richie

One thing is clear: a 13th century Rabbi cannot be mentioned in the Talmud. The author must mean that he is mentioned in a commentary on the Talmud, such as Tosfot. Can you cite the source?

Apr 02, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
I NEED PROOF OF THIS
by: YITZI

Rabbi Joseph of Lincoln was a scholar mentioned in the Talmud

bx1935@sbcglobal.net

Mar 10, 2008
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Lincoln a Jewish President?
by: Nathan in Philadelphia

Wow, when I first heard of this on local radio show I was thinking it was a joke the way they portrayed the story. Now I read this note from Rabbi Jeff Kahn in New Jersey and have to wonder myself.

Not that religion dictates one man's good versus another but Lincoln was one heck of a Prsident in any stretch of the imagination. He managed a country completely divided and headed in polarized directions.

What a great addition, if true, to the Jewish heritage!

Nathan

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How?
Simply click here to return to Suggest A Forum Topic